Wednesday, 27 February 2013

Proprietors of Community trademarks are protected against use of their marks by all third parties, including parties holding a later registration in their own name. Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union dated 21 February 2013, Fédération Cynologique Internationale v Federación Canina Internacional de Perros de Pura Raza (C-561/11)


1. Background. The Fédération Cynologique Internationale, proprietors of Community trademark no. 4438751 FCI FEDERACION CYNOLOGIQUE INTERNATIONALES in Classes 35, 41, 42, and 44, lodged a trademark infringement action with Community Trade Mark Court No. 1 in Alicante against Federación Canina Internacional de Perros de Pura Raza, who were themselves the proprietors of various Spanish trademark registrations for FCI (one senior to complainants' Community trademark) as well as a Community trademark registration for FCI (figurative).




With an eye to the facts in this case, the Community Trade Mark Court in Alicante raised the issue of whether the rights conferred by a Community trademark registration entitle the proprietor to prohibit the owner of another registered trademark from using that mark or, by contrast, trademark infringement proceedings are conditional upon first or concomitantly invalidating the defendant's Community trademark.

In the circumstances the Spanish court decided to stay the proceedings and refer the question to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling with a view to ascertaining the actual scope of Article 9.1 of the Community Trade Mark Regulation, and in particular whether the words "all third parties" mean that a third party may be prevented from using his own trademark registration before that later trademark registration has been declared invalid.

2.  Findings. In paragraph 33 of the judgment (C-561/11), the Court states explicitly that "… Article 9(1) of the Regulation does not make any distinction on the basis of whether the third party is the proprietor of a Community trade mark or not" and afterwards goes on to add that, as it had already made plain in a Community design matter (judgment of 16 February 2012, Celaya, Case C-488/10), "… that provision grants the proprietor of a Community trade mark an exclusive right to prevent 'any third party', not having its consent, from using, in the course of trade, any signs liable to infringe its mark".

But the Court does not stop there. It also states that "… the proprietor of a Community trade mark is entitled both to apply to OHIM for a declaration of invalidity of the later Community trade mark and to oppose its use through infringement proceedings before a Community trade mark court." The court thus views these two actions as alternatives, as options to which the proprietor of a Community trade mark registration is entitled.

The Court interprets the provisions of the Community Trade Mark Regulation in light of the "priority principle", under which the earlier Community mark takes precedence over a later Community mark.

The court concludes by affirming that "… if the proprietor of an earlier trade mark, in order to prevent the use by a third party of a sign that is liable to affect the functions of its trade mark, were required to await the declaration of invalidity of the later Community mark held by that third party, the protection accorded to it by Article 9(1) of the Regulation would be significantly weakened" (paragraph 51).

3. Remarks. The judgment sets out exactly the same position the Court took in the matter of Community designs (judgment of 16 February 2012, Celaya, Case C-488/10). While this does afford the proprietor of an earlier trade mark registration some certainty, by the same token it is somewhat at odds with the obligation all trademark proprietors are under to use their mark. According to this recent judgment, the proprietor of a later registration will be in a weak and vulnerable position when he first commences using his mark.

However, in its judgment the Court does not enter into any deliberation on the final consideration set forth obiter dictum in paragraph 55 of the Advocate General's opinion, namely, "were the Court to accept the interpretation of the term 'third party' …, that interpretation would have also to include a third party who is the holder of a later registered trade mark in a Member State, regardless of the substance of the relevant national legislation."

In this regard it is important to note that the stance taken by the Supreme Court of Spain is quite different from the position taken by the Court of Justice. The Spanish Supreme Court takes the view that to be able to find that infringement has taken place, and consequently that there is liability for damages, there must also be a previous or concomitant ruling invalidating the later infringing registration (judgment of Chamber I of the Supreme Court on 4 April 2012) (in Spanish).

This difference will definitely have to be taken into account when taking legal action and, above all, when deciding whether to file for a Spanish or a Community trademark. There is also a chance that the Spanish Supreme Court may revise its position based on the judgment issued by the Court of Justice. We will therefore have to be alert to future developments. 

Author: Luis Baz

Visit our website: http://www.elzaburu.es/


5 comments:

  1. The ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union on 21 February 2013, regarding the protection of community trademarks, reinforces the importance of safeguarding these marks against unauthorized use, even by parties with later registrations. This decision is a reminder of how critical it is to protect intellectual property, similar to how in wordle unlimited, each move and guess matters in securing the correct answer.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The concept of community trademarks is an interesting one, as it allows businesses to secure branding rights across multiple regions or even entire communities. It’s a bit like how in moto x3m, you need to navigate and conquer different obstacles in various levels — similarly.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For anyone looking to build their own trademark, consider the creativity and strategy involved in building a brand, similar to how players develop their characters and businesses in the game Bitlife

    ReplyDelete
  4. The decision of the Court of Justice of the European Union in this case confirms the principle of priority of Community marks, which agario provides strong protection for trademark owners against third parties, even when the third parties also have a registered trademark.

    ReplyDelete
  5. play tetris Online: Enjoy the Ultimate Classic Puzzle Game
    Ready to experience the timeless thrill of Tetris? Play Tetris online and dive into one of the most iconic puzzle games ever created. Since its debut in 1984, Tetris has remained a favorite for gamers of all ages, blending simplicity, challenge, and endless replayability.

    🎮 What Is Tetris?
    Tetris is a legendary puzzle game where players arrange falling blocks (tetrominoes) to form complete lines. When a line is cleared, it disappears—earning you points and making room for more. The longer you play, the faster the blocks fall!

    🕹️ The Origin of Tetris
    Created by Russian software engineer Alexey Pajitnov in 1984, Tetris quickly spread from the Soviet Union to the world. It became a global gaming phenomenon, especially with its launch on the Nintendo Game Boy, which helped sell millions of units worldwide.

    🌟 Why Tetris Remains Popular in 2025
    Tetris continues to thrive thanks to its:

    ✅ Easy-to-learn gameplay

    ✅ Challenging mechanics for all skill levels

    ✅ Universal appeal across generations

    ✅ Infinite replay value

    🔧 How to Play Tetris Online
    The goal is simple: fit the falling blocks together to clear horizontal lines. But as the speed increases, so does the challenge!

    📱 Basic Tetris Controls:
    ← / → Arrow Keys – Move blocks left or right

    ↑ Arrow Key – Rotate the block

    ↓ Arrow Key – Soft drop

    Spacebar – Hard drop instantly

    🌐 Play Tetris Online for Free – No Download Needed
    Play the modern version of Tetris directly in your browser with:

    🎮 Smooth and fast gameplay

    🧩 Multiple difficulty levels and modes

    🌍 Global leaderboards to compete worldwide

    💻 No installation required – play instantly online

    Visit Tetris.one and play Tetris online anytime, anywhere.

    🧠 Mental Benefits of Playing Tetris
    Tetris is not just fun—it’s good for your brain! Studies show that Tetris can:

    ✅ Improve spatial awareness

    ✅ Boost problem-solving skills

    ✅ Enhance hand-eye coordination

    ✅ Develop fast decision-making

    🎯 Conclusion: Play Tetris Online Today
    Whether you’re revisiting a childhood favorite or trying it for the first time, Tetris offers endless fun and cognitive benefits. With its easy access and addictive gameplay, it’s no wonder Tetris remains one of the most played games in history.

    👉 Start playing now at Tetris.one — no download, no hassle, just pure puzzle fun.

    🔎 SEO Title:
    Play Tetris Online for Free | Classic Puzzle Game in Your Browser

    📝 Meta Description:
    Play Tetris online for free with no downloads. Enjoy the classic puzzle game with modern graphics, global leaderboards, and real-time gameplay. Start now at Tetris.one.

    ReplyDelete